Sometimes we reviewers
see films that are, frankly, quite unpleasant -- like
bad-tasting medicine. But the purpose of medicine is to
make you better, and so it goes that these kinds of
films do too.
Directed by Fabrizio
Lazzaretti, Guiseppe Petitto and Alberto Vendemmiati,
the new documentary "Jung (War) In the Land of the
Mujaheddin" may not make you feel better, exactly, but
it will enlighten you, expand your thought process, and
lift you out of the Hollywood Matrix that prefers to
batter you with military recruitment films disguised as
"Saving Private Ryan" and the like.
"Jung (War) In the Land of
the Mujaheddin," which opens today at the Roxie, would
most likely have stirred little interest in the U.S. had
the 9/11 attacks never happened, but now it appears as
fresh and painful as a clip from today's headlines.
(Incidentally, "Jung" is pronounced "jang" and means
"war.")
In the film, our three
filmmakers travel to Afghanistan in 1999 and 2000 to
document the efforts of one Dr. Gino Strada, who wishes
to establish a hospital to care for the victims of
Taliban rule, many of whom have been injured by land
mines. Kate Rowlands, a British nurse, and Ettore Mo, an
Italian journalist, are his companions.
We learn that war in
Afghanistan has raged for 20 years and that 1.5 million
have died. ("They will always fight each other -- they
will always need war to live," says one interviewee.)
The filmmakers interview children who have lost limbs in
land-mine explosions, families who have lost their
homes, and Northern Alliance fighters -- including the
famous "Lion of the Panjshir" who was assassinated just
before Sept. 11.
Our filmmakers frequently
find themselves on the battlefront with real bullets
whizzing over their heads and real tanks creeping by.
Unlike those in Hollywood war movies, the camera in this
film shakes when an explosion erupts nearby, and we
sense that the danger is very real. At one point, the
doctor explains that his new hospital site is a
potential target because of the many tanks parked
nearby.
The film's success comes not
so much from its filmic style than from its fearless
recording of this subject matter. But when Ettore Mo
explains that as a journalist he's more interested in
the small details -- the hidden stories -- rather than
politics or military strategies, he sums up the film
very nicely. We never learn how this conflict started,
and we're not even sure if these combatants and
civilians themselves know. It's just that they've been
taught to hate an enemy, just as that enemy has been
taught to hate them. (We witness some down-and-out
civilians who simply wish that the Taliban would "go
away.")
Those with weak stomachs
should probably not view "Jung (War) In the Land of the
Mujaheddin," as the film does not shy away from the most
horrible aspects of this war, from rotted corpses to
bloody stumps to mutilated children. For the rest of us,
the truth does indeed hurt.
E-mail Jeffrey M. Anderson
at janderson@sfexaminer.com.